After eight months in charge of Newcastle's overwhelmingly underwhelming transfer activity, Joe Kinnear has resigned as the club's director of football, in the latest twist of the Irishman's bizarre Tyneside adventure.
As shocked as the fans were that he was the replacement for Kevin Keegan as manager back in 2008, to be put in charge of Newcastle's recruitment drive last summer really took the biscuit for strange decisions made by Mike Ashley. Alan Pardew was already feeling the heat after a desperately disappointing 16th place last season, and Kinnear's appointment read like a blatant attempt to undermine him ahead of the new season.
Against all the odds however, Pardew has outlasted Kinnear, with the boss becoming more and more frustrated with a transfer policy that has yielded only two loan signings and the sale of star player Yohan Cabaye. Pardew, in the wake of the shocking 3-0 home defeat to Sunderland, intimated that if he was in charge of player incomings things would have been different - it looks like Kinnear has listened, and jumped before being pushed.
More cynical observers would suggest that Kinnear was merely doing the job set out for him by Ashley. Newcastle have been the most profitable club in all the most recent transfer windows, so from a business point of view the Irishman hasn't done badly. From a football point of view however, the perspective that the manager and fans hold, he badly let the club down. In a season of transition for all the top clubs, with a bit of ambition Newcastle could have been fighting it out for fourth place. Instead, a top-half finish will take some doing, with form and morale low.
Ambition doesn't have to mean splashing millions out on players the club can't afford, as was the case when Freddie Shepherd held ownership. However, to not ensure the replacement of players like Cabaye, or properly strengthen the attack, leaves Newcastle in danger of losing what quality they have. Yet again, an opportunity has been missed, and one suspects that with Ashley in charge the pattern will continue.
Showing posts with label Joe Kinnear. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Joe Kinnear. Show all posts
Tuesday, 4 February 2014
Thursday, 22 August 2013
Murky Waters Of The Tyne.
The bell for round two was sounded on Monday evening, taking
the form of a referee’s whistle. This season threatened to be more of the same
for Newcastle before a ball had even been kicked, with a summer of
unsatisfactory transfer (in)activity behind them.
Within 45 minutes at the Etihad Stadium, two goals down and
a man light, the Magpies were on the ropes, already struggling for breath,
looking to their corner for inspiration. They could have been forgiven for
wondering exactly who to turn to. Alan Pardew brought smiles to the faces of
players and fans alike with a stunning first full season in charge, but lately
has been giving the impression of a joyless puppet, as the walls close in
around him.
Joe Kinnear was brought in to help the boss with transfers, yet the
only addition to the squad has been the on-loan signing of a player, Loic Remy,
who Newcastle nearly signed in January. Oh, and since then he has become
embroiled in controversial off-the-pitch legal stew. Valid questions can be
asked about his temperament, but his ability and strike-rate for another
struggling side in QPR cannot be denied.
The summer has mainly seen the dream team of Pardew and
Kinnear making noises about possible signings, with ‘getting them over the line’
being the buzz phrase of choice. Well as things stand, getting the ball over
one line and keeping it from crossing another are both proving troublesome.
With Steven Taylor banned for three games, and Santon remaining inexplicably injured,
Mike Williamson is within touching distance of game time, an outcome that will
leave many heads in hands.
To get the season on the right track, and avoid a relegation
scrap, many things are required. Unfortunately, a change of manager (and
director of football for that matter) should be high on the agenda, as even
that would lead to better performances from a group of players that have lost
their motivation, their drive, and pride for the shirt, if it ever existed in
the first place for the Frenchmen.
Next, is a replacement for Yohan Cabaye, who, while
immensely talented, is obviously unhappy on Tyneside. A winger, a forward, and
another centre-back are also needed, before anyone else even leaves. One thing
is for sure – Cabaye is what attracted a lot of the better French players to
the club. With his departure, many will follow.
With home games against West Ham and Fulham to come, four
points are a minimum requirement for anyone looking to claim Newcastle are
heading in the right direction. A small percentage of Newcastle fans will
doubtlessly be hoping for a complete implosion in the next couple of weeks in
order to rid themselves of the unholy trinity, but one would hope the eleven
that takes the field will retain a decent level of support, or the club may
find itself in a relegation tailspin that no manager can reverse.
Labels:
Alan Pardew,
Joe Kinnear,
Loic Remy,
Newcastle,
Yohan Cabaye
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)